Should India attack Pakistan after Taj attack?

i
what do you think should India attack Pakistan after Mumbai tragic.
I don't think so, because Pakistan isn't the one who attacked us. Attacking Pakistan will lead to a war, and war is not the solution to all this.

What is your opinion?

-Girish


Reply 1

Yes, an eye for an eye will get us nowhere. It will only create more bloodshed. Peace and harmony are more important than war, no matter that terrorist outfits in Pakistan are involved in attacks on India. Eventually, it is the innocent citizens who will suffer.

Quote of the Day: A crystal-clear plan is waiting right there; just reach out and take it – it’s yours through prayer. ~Author Unknown


Reply 2

Come on Vandana.. Are you very much in this world?
Peace and Harmony... Are you sure today its time to take action with peace and harmony.. we have maintained peace for long may be too long ..thats the reason.. we were happy in our so called peaceful and happy world and outsiders attacked us..

We were talking about peace..they attacked Delhi
We were talking about peace..they attacked Banglore
We were talking about peace..they attacked Ahemdabad
We were talking about peace..they attacked Mumbai

So what do you want now.. let them add one city after another to the list...
Its not time to maintain peace..
Even figting technique like Kung-Fu's first lesson is:

Never use your knowledge to attack someone..Always use it to defend yourself from attacks of others...

Its time to attack...
They showed us their potential.. They have nuclear weapon with them..
So if we maintian peace.. definition of peace will change for ever...

Charge them and attack them... Enough is Enough


Reply 3

yes, Attacking Pakistan will lead to a war, and war is not the solution.Because war leads to many problems than solving the problems.
according to my point of view,its not a great act to commence war on Pakisthan because of Mumbai tragic.


Reply 4

Hi Girish, Attacking Pakistan is not our motive. We have to be more careful in self-defence. We have to strengthen our defence . Talking about peace wont do good when someone attacking you . If required we should be ready for a counter attack .


Reply 5

I also do not support attack on Pakistan but I am in support of strengthen our defence system.
Varun, think about the after effects of the Afganistan attack by America, there were pictures of toddlers who lost their limbs,lost an eye, became deformed etc, crying helplessly. It was horryfying to see those sights.Maybe from a different nation but they are also innocent kids.
My point is how can we, sensible people, commit the same crime by killing innocent people of Pakistan as done by the terrorists. That does not mean I want more terror attacks, but things to be solved diplomatically, creating political pressures, like boycotting Pakistan, treating thm as third degree citizens etc.
A n eye for an eye is no big deal for dealing with such issues. We should use our brains to handle this crisis. How can we, sensible people, become emotionless, animals like the terrorists?


Reply 6

Attacking Pakistan will not solve problems.Many innocent people will lose life.Country is already going thrpugh financial crisis.Central Govt instability, financial crisis- all will increase if we start a war
We should get more support from all over the world & Pakistan should be pressurised to hand over terrorists & stop such activities


Reply 7

Hi vandana,
good topic choosen for discussion. Are you very much in this world?
Peace and Harmony... Are you sure today its time to take action with peace and harmony.. we have maintained peace for long may be too long ..thats the reason.. we were happy in our so called peaceful and happy world and outsiders attacked us..
We were talking about peace..they attacked Delhi,We were talking about peace..they attacked Banglore,We were talking about peace..they attacked Ahemdabad,We were talking about peace..they attacked Mumbai
So what do you want now.. let them add one city after another to the list...
Its not time to maintain peace..
Even figting technique like Kung-Fu's first lesson is:
Never use your knowledge to attack someone..Always use it to defend yourself from attacks of others...
Its time to attack...They showed us their potential.. They have nuclear weapon with them.. So if we maintian peace.. definition of peace will change for ever...
Charge them and attack them... Enough is Enough,, good topic


Reply 8

Friends, just think.. Have you ever thought of slapping somebody for he did some nonsense with you? May be in the second thought you would think otherwise - if he retaliates. So, attacking is no way a wise decision. Let us strengthen ourselves, our internal security so much that nobody can dare to attack us. On offense, there is always a risk of retaliation and the process never ends.
If we are talking about war, this will surely be a blunder on our part. Because, all the peer nations like China and others they want us to do so, so that our envious economic growth would be shattered in their advantage. Today an economically vibrant country garners more respect than a warrior country. So, with the best economy, an insulated border and clean mind politicians we will feel more safe than in a war torn nation.


Reply 9

One of my Muslim friend made a good point about this question. It is not in best interest of India to start war or attack Pakistan on Mumbai terrosit attack. This will take Pakistan forces away from Afghan border trying to fight Al Quaida and Taliban and it will give these extremist freedom to create more trouble elsewhere instead of that let them kill each other why do we want to waste Indian forces effort for the work that Islamic extremist are doing to Pakistan. We should spend our resources in strenghtening our security and defence.


Reply 10

Very good thinking. As we all know world is under Global Economic crisis.So a war will weaken India more .This will be an advantage for other countries other than Pakistan who are the Economic enimies of India. So we should quite now. Let us hope US and UN will make any action .


Reply 11

if we take an action against them then what will be the difference left between us both.its time for us to be united and protect ourselves first.we have to make our country strong.and then start attacking the enimies. even they want the same. they want to create some disturbances between us. and if we really do so they will be the successors.what are they really trying to prove by doing so.
better we learn how to defend ourselves first.
we are proud to be INDIANS. a country resembling peace.
if they really want to see the second side of our country " the dangerous side" which will teach them a lesson then we will definetly. i mean if they dont stop causing terror in our country.


Reply 12

We must never attack Pakistan or any neighbour country on these basis of terror, we must first fight with corruption in our country, we must first fight with in house terrorist, Every public has to understand his power of vote, his power to right of Information, The main cause of corruption the politicians, who make situation to divide indians in different ways, like, state, language, religion,
we must first strength our boundaries, our home to fight against our neighbour,
It is not fair to attack or fight without any reason like a child



Reply 13

Isn't that really a sudden rage or reflex. Why should we attack Pakistan? Did Pakistan really did it? Is there any way we can prove it?
Humans are gifted with different attributes to tackle down problems?
Why destroy our own GOOD COLORS for bad?
That isn't a good way to stop terrorism. We can always remain in safer hands and usher problems into good talks?
Waging war against one country may give way to ALL the countries and obviously THIRD WORLD WAR will be fought with stones for NOW the ammunition are not that useless bullets, they are nuclear powers which can annihilate the size of earth thrice. Do you want that to happen or do you want it to happen in other way round where peace in always the ULTIMATE CONCERN. Let us not allow Government to take abrupt decisions and we are sure we are only going to do this rubbish over the net and at the batlle, let 'JAWAANS' toil between life and death. The consequences of this war will be real UNFATHOMABLE DESTRUCTION.
And India is most probably initiating ANTI-TERRORIST COMMANDOS(If I can know about it?)
Let the mother nature be in bliss, PLEASE!!!

Reply 14

I strongly agree with Varun Sharma. This is not blood for blood. This just to show our strength and our strategy aganst terrorrism.
May be present economic conditions are not suitable for WAR. Otherwise defnitely we have to go for a war , and show what we are.
If you want to achive your goal you need a weapon, peace always doesnt solve problems.


Reply 15

India should not attcak Pakistan after the Taj attack. What happened on 26th Nov was unfortunate, but to retaliate by attacking is not the way according to me.
But it does not mean that Pakistan should be spared for it.Some action has to be taken,but I dont know what.Its for our leaders to decided.
Secondly, I believe India at present is not in a position to initiate a war.Already our economy is trembling and to initiate war at this time is not adviseable.
Still something has to be done, one way or the other. India has to teach Pakistan some lesson.
Leaders please wake up and do something.



Reply 16


i also agree with you.if india will attack pakistan it will lead to
war.we can solve this problem using peace only


Reply 17

It seems majority of us think that war is not the solution at this point of time, instead we should focus more on our defence system and a strong political hold. however, some of us think that it is time to retaliate which is also justified as India has suffered a lot and it is obvious if people wants to retaliate after the massacre.
But do you think it will be beneficial if India alone goes for a war to clean up the terrorist mess?


Reply 18

It seems majority of us think that war is not the solution at this point of time, instead we should focus more on our defence system and a strong political hold. however, some of us think that it is time to retaliate which is also justified as India has suffered a lot and it is obvious if people wants to retaliate after the massacre.But it does not mean that Pakistan should be spared for it.Some action has to be taken,but I dont know what.Its for our leaders to decided.
Secondly, I believe India at present is not in a position to initiate a war.Already our economy is trembling and to initiate war at this time is not adviseable.This is not blood for blood. This just to show our strength and our strategy aganst terrorrism.
May be present economic conditions are not suitable for WAR. Otherwise defnitely we have to go for a war , and show what we are.
If you want to achive your goal you need a weapon, peace always doesnt solve problems.


Still something has to be done, one way or the other. India has to teach Pakistan some lesson


Reply 19

Dear Raghu Ram. K, you have copied the contents written by me, Sidharth Mahajan and Raja Ramesh Varma. Not a single line has been written by yourself. In ISC we all work hard and post our own resources and comments in our own words. These shortcuts are not encouraged in this site.
If you want to share your views, please use your own words and do not copy contents from others.
If your post is reported to the WebMaster, you will loose all your points.


Reply 20

Frens,erase off the scanario of two countries.Place urself as India and ur neighbour as Pakistan and wud you opt for peace talks when the next-door person carries on a killing-spree.Yes you wud,bt how many a times???once,twice or let it be ten times. Will you not lodge a complaint against him(the minimum/least of reactionns).As a matter of fact,we would hardly bear even a small robbery...Then,how do u guys see this as a different one. As Shah Rukh Stated,DO not spit on the faces unless they step foot on ur doorsteps.but if they,then.........The statements on peace talks etc etc etc are all sympathising....EMPATHISE frens,Place urself in that position.put yourself into the shoes of those miserable people..Even in the Bhagvad gita,Lord Krishna has stated,If thr is someone all set to kill you,then it makes no sense to sit beside him,talk to him and explain to him the right and the wrong,RATHER do what you can that would defend yourself.Wake up frens,Peace talks are going to do nothing.And some frens were pointing out that the INNOCENT people of pakistan will be killed,let me ask u onething WHO WERE THE ONES KILLED BRUTALLY IN THIS SOIL?? DONT THEY CONSTITUTE THIS "INNOCENT PEOPLE"??Its purely ABSURD to say Patience will reap.ALl i would say is do not go about intimating,peace talks that this....these r al not gona work.
SECONDLY,I would also go parallel to some comments that said to intensify our security.THATS TRUE.INDEED TRUE.But unfortunately its never going to happen.This is not democracy.RE-DEFINE DEMOCRACY.Each politician roughly has 20 Gundas(minimum) to perform all kinds of attrocities in the name of democracy.Who gave them these many powers??IS THIS NOT INTERNAL TERRORISM and we are all talking about FIGHTING EXTERNAL TERRORISM-WHICH IS TRUELY NOT HAPPENING FRENS.RE-DEFINE DEMOCRACY.
So conclusively i personlly feel that india should react to this unforgivable-act.not necessarily a war,agreed,but that should always be in mind.AFTER-ALL ITS NOT ATTACKING ,IYTS ABOUT SELF-DEFENDING.


Reply 21

i think war is no the solution of this problrm...then what would be the diifference b/w us n them...no doubt they have tried their best to break our integrity n unity...bt did they get succeeed..?no...istead we are geetting more united..
if we attack at them..they would get suuceess in wt they always wanted...india is a peaceful country...its aatack on PAk...will raise the aagressiveness in the muslims in india too..n thats goona effect our countries peace...we can distrupt pak with in few mins..becoz we are more strong than them...bt we will effect our own country...war is not the soluntion of every thing....
let it do what it want...just make urself more stronger n stronger...they agin won't dare to take this step


Reply 22

It is true that we are gradually forced to do the war.

But it is for our shake we are thinking a bit.

1. The Taliban and Pakistan will be united.
2. In war they have nothing to lost, they don't have any thing to be destroyed. They don't have any developed city, or industry. The destruction will be for India, It is true that we will won the battle. But in what price.

3. This is time of economic recession. A war will lead the country into a financial weak situation.